Showing posts with label materialism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label materialism. Show all posts

Sunday, 16 March 2014

Engels on China

From Comments at The Virtual Politician:

philstanfield

Worth considering: ‘The war in China has given the death-blow to the old China. Isolation has become impossible; the introduction of railways, steam-engines, electricity, and modern large-scale industry has become a necessity, if only for reasons of military defence. But with it the old economic system of small peasant agriculture, where the family also made its industrial products itself, falls to pieces too, and with it the whole old social system which made relatively dense population possible. Millions will be turned out and forced to emigrate; and these millions will find their way even to Europe, and en masse. But as soon as Chinese competition sets in on a mass scale, it will rapidly bring things to a head in your country and over here, and thus the conquest of China by capitalism will at the same time furnish the impulse for the overthrow of capitalism in Europe and America…’

Engels to Friedrich Adolf Sorge in Hoboken; London, November 10, 1894, Marx Engels, Selected Correspondence, Progress Publishers, Moscow, 1982, 450-451
--

zeroBelief

I am unfamiliar with Engels and Friedrich Adolf Sorge, let alone their designs upon destroying American and European capitalism. Might you expound a bit on that for us?

Thanks!!!
--

philstanfield

Hello zeroBelief,

Thank you for your interest. Essentially I quoted Engels not to argue for destruction but for how the world works – that the only absolute is change and that matter (objective reality) is primary to consciousness (that consciousness is the product of objective reality – what one thinks, whatever that may be, is secondary to and derivate of the world). Accepting these two points orients and focuses one’s thought on all subjects.

The one-party state in China, as you know, is demonised in capitalist ideology. Western democracy is held up as the highest form of political organisation, the standard. But look not only at the damage the Democrat/Republican divide is doing in the United States (and to the world – echoes of of which division are playing out in Australia where I live, with similar hostility between Labor and Liberal parties, and in other capitalist nations), think of the enormous forces – economic and social, that are being impacted on by these divisions.

In China with its population of 1.3 billion (and as Engels foresaw) is taking place rapid economic development, following on the reforms of Deng Xiaoping. With that development, and dialectically informing it, is the equally rapid rise of millions into the middle class. The middle class has historically been the agent of democracy as we know it and I believe that this rising middle class in China (as it has done everywhere else) will put increasing pressure for economic influence and a political voice on their one-party state and that the inter-relationship of these two (party and middle class) will result in forms of political, economic and social organisation that will be models for the world.

I think that these developments, together with the benefits they bring, underscored by the vast size of the Chinese population will force similar and fundamental economic, political and social change on the Western (capitalist) nations. And this is what Engels foresaw in 1894, in outline. We are witnessing and experiencing the unceasing, contradictory change of dialectics at work.

Regards, Philip


Saturday, 8 March 2014

What does materialism have to do with mysticism?

Not only is materialism indebted to mysticism - as Marx implicitly acknowledged when he correctly described the Christian Neoplatonist Hegel’s philosophy as mystical1 - mysticism and its influence pervade Western culture.

The contribution of mysticism in all areas has been profound - to literature, the visual arts, religion, particularly to and through philosophy with its concealed priesthood (which priesthood was identified by the overt priest Nietzsche), to science - it inspired Copernicus to the greatest scientific hypothesis, and Kepler. In the West, its primarily Neoplatonic form, in reflecting the contradictory, poetic dynamism of the world - and having been stood on its feet by Marx - became the engine of dialectical materialism itself.2

We, in the West, on the back of all that has been achieved, believe a monumental lie, a monumental arrogance, a monumental delusion - that while others worship idols, stare at their navels, are committed to 'failed' or 'backward' ideologies or are obsessed with filial piety, we have risen above this to become the triumphal bearers of millennial ‘Reason’. We wear this self-awarded badge of ‘Reason’ as a cultural definition. It is the belief we have relied on to most distinguish the West from the rest.

The impact of mysticism argues against this. Linguistic reason, a core tool of all authoritarians from Plato onwards, is not the only form of reason. At the heart of mysticism is another - powerful and fluid, complex, subtle and evanescent. And in the inspiration of its 'connectedness', immensely creative.

Linguistic reason draws on this 'connectedness' as its proponents seek to contain and deny it. The artist and theologian Plato is a prime example. I refer you to the lyrical power of the Ion:

For a Poet is indeed a thing ethereally light, winged, and sacred...

Linguistic reason, while reason’s jewel, is but its tip. When we wake in the middle of the night with the solution to a long-standing problem, had we been dotting every ‘i’ and crossing every ‘t’, or might trotting chairs and fluttering wings have borne fruit in creative 'space'?

Or when you round a corner and bump into a stranger - no time for considered words and structured sentences - think of the richness, at multiple levels, of what has taken place in your brain - in a moment's silence. Such a cognitive experience (that of 'first impressions') is so intense it merges seamlessly with the physical. This thinking is the ever-present underlay of what is done linguistically.

Intuitive thought draws most directly on our connectedness - to all that comprises us, to what we remember, and to the world. It provides us with perhaps our deepest cognitive experience of the world. That this has been given not only religious but mystical meaning does not detract from its objective nature and potential.

In considering what comprises 'reason', the materialist must begin with how the brain functions in its totality, recognising that those functions bear on the whole dialectically, that they are inseparable and plastic, and not focus only on the brain's capacity for its highest product - linguistic expression.

Notes
1. Marx wrote: ‘I therefore openly avowed myself the pupil of that mighty thinker...The mystification which the dialectic suffers in Hegel’s hands by no means prevents him from being the first to present its general forms of motion in a comprehensive and conscious manner. With him it is standing on its head. It must be inverted, in order to discover the rational kernel within the mystical shell.‘ Karl Marx, Capital, vol. 1, Postface to the Second Edition 1873, Penguin, London, 1982, p. 103.

2. See William Franke's two volume anthology On What Cannot Be Said: Apophatic Discourses in Philosophy, Religion, Literature, and the Arts, University of Notre Dame Press, Notre Dame, Indiana, 2007

*   *   *